Skip to content

Pre-Mortem Analysis

Why It Matters

Prospective thinking ("how could this go wrong?") is weak - people are optimistic about their own ideas and miss failure modes. Pre-mortem reverses this: assuming failure has occurred bypasses optimism bias and activates explanation mode, which is much better at identifying causes. This surfaces risks that traditional planning misses.

The Key Move

Gather your team. Say: "It's [time period] from now. Our solution has failed spectacularly. It's a disaster." Ask everyone to write independently: What happened? What caused the failure? Collect all failure stories. Look for patterns - what failure modes appear multiple times? What risks hadn't you considered? Design interventions specifically to prevent the most likely and most catastrophic failure modes identified.

Classic Application

Gary Klein documented pre-mortems in medical and military contexts. Example: surgical teams doing pre-mortems before complex procedures identified failure modes (communication breakdowns during shift changes, missing instruments, patient ID confusion) that weren't in standard checklists. Designing interventions for these pre-mortem scenarios reduced surgical complications.

Surprising Application

Relationship decisions (moving in together, marriage, business partnerships). Standard approach: discuss hopes and plans. Pre-mortem: "It's 2 years from now and we've split up badly. What happened?" This surfaces deal-breakers, incompatibilities, and assumption conflicts that optimistic planning conceals. Better to discover these before commitment than after. Often this strengthens the relationship by addressing issues preemptively.

Failure Modes

Using pre-mortem to justify pessimism or kill ideas - the goal is improvement, not cancellation. Generating only generic failures ("we ran out of money") rather than specific mechanisms. Not following through - identifying failure modes but not designing preventions. Doing pre-mortem too early when you don't understand the solution well enough. Confusing pre-mortem with risk register - it's not about listing risks, but about activating hindsight mode while you can still prevent the failures.

Go Deeper

Klein, "Performing a Project Premortem" (Harvard Business Review, 2007); Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, Chapter 24